If you thought you couldn’t make fudgy brownies without a box mix…you were wrong. (Jump to Recipe)
I know you. You’re like me. How do I know this?
Well, if you’re reading this page, you have an interest in the real kind of baking; the creaming butter, sifting flour, whisking in eggs, folding in chocolate kind of baking. Some people say they like baking, but when they say that, they really mean the “dump mix into bowl with water oil and eggs” kind of baking. And don’t get me wrong – there is a time and place for that kind of baking, and there’s no problem with it, if that’s your thing.
But we all know, that’s not my thing.
I’m a get-your-hands-dirty, make-your-own, homemade-is-best kind of girl, and I’m not ashamed to admit it. I make my own nut butters and cinnamon rolls, and you will not see me using a cake mix unless I have run out of all other ingredients and it’s an emergency.
But brownies. Brownies, well, they’ve given me some trouble.
I’ve been trying for years (honestly, years) to concoct a homemade, from-scratch fudgy brownie recipe that was ACTUALLY FUDGY, and not essentially chocolate cake hinting at fudginess or bordering on fudgy. I kept wondering to myself: why is it that all homemade brownie recipes seem to produce dry and cakey brownies, no matter how fudgy they promise to be? Are we really unable to replicate the luscious, deep chocolate flavor and texture of a boxed brownie at home?
Yet again and again, I tried and failed. So, embarrassingly, up until now, when I’ve wanted fudgy brownies, I’ve resorted to a box mix. I am not proud of this.
(I will say that Trader Joe’s Truffle Brownie Mix is insanely, insanely good for a box mix. But still, it irked me. I knew I could do better.)
The Chocolate Factor
I thought perhaps it was a problem with my go-to recipe (you saw a version with these Midnight Brownies), adapted from Dorie Greenspan. You see, some recipes use melted chocolate, and some recipes use cocoa powder mixed with butter. That recipe uses cocoa powder. I surmised that maybe using cocoa powder added too little fat and resulting moisture, meaning the brownies became drier and more cake-like as they baked. So I tried a couple recipes that used melted chocolate, and more butter, instead. They were slightly better, but I found them overpoweringly rich and still just not the right texture.
It wasn’t until I saw the recipe Sally’s Baking Addiction posted for fudgy brownies that I realized the secret: you have to use melted chocolate AND cocoa powder, not either or. I messed around with some ratios in my normal brownie recipe, and …Eureka!! Fudgy brownies with intense chocolate flavor! Sally is a genius.
So, there are not one, not two, but THREE forms of chocolate in these brownies: melted chocolate, cocoa powder, and chocolate chips. If I’m going to make something chocolatey, you better believe I’m going all the way.
Brian has declared these “the best brownies he’s ever had” which, to me, is quite a compliment. He’s eaten quite a few brownies in his life. I clearly have too, and I have to say, I don’t think I need another brownie recipe. This is the one. It has the texture and flavor of the deepest chocolate fudgy brownies, and to be honest, I think it’s even better than a box mix.
A few important notes before we go:
- Don’t skimp on the sugar. A cup of sugar may seem like a lot, but since we’re using unsweetened cocoa powder here, we need make up for it. Plus, the sugar creates that beautiful shiny papery crust we all love so much.
- Don’t use a mixer – a bowl and a spoon is the name of the game here. You don’t want to whip too much air into these brownies because we want them to be dense, and it’s way too easy to overmix with a mixer.
- The recipe calls for a small amount of espresso powder, which enhances the chocolate flavor without tasting like espresso. You can buy it at most grocery stores or Amazon. It’s ok if you don’t have it, but I HIGHLY recommend it.
- Definitely put coarse sea salt on top once the brownies are baked. Similar to the espresso powder, the salt brings out the sweetness and chocolate flavor. They were made for each other.
Ok, let’s do this! I hope you love these as much as we do.
If you thought you couldn't make fudgy brownies without a box mix...you were wrong.
- 6 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1/4 cup chopped dark chocolate or chocolate chips (1 oz)
- 1 cup granulated sugar (you can go a little under, but stay above 3/4 cup)
- 2 large eggs
- 1/4 teaspoon espresso powder (optional)*
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 cup cocoa powder
- 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup chocolate chips
- Coarse sea salt, for sprinkling on top
-
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F. Grease an 8x8 square pan or line with parchment paper. Set aside.
-
In a large microwave-safe bowl, melt the butter and 1/4 cup chopped chocolate or chocolate chips in 30-second intervals, stirring in between, until melted and smooth. This took about 1 minute in my microwave.
-
Whisk in the sugar. If the mixture is really hot, let it cool for a minute before whisking in the eggs one at a time (you don't want to cook the eggs!), until fully combined.
-
Whisk in the espresso powder, vanilla, salt, and cocoa powder until the mixture is smooth and well-combined. Stir in the flour just until the mixture is smooth and you no longer see clumps - but do not overmix, and don't use a mixer. We don't want to incorporate too much air in the batter, or the brownies won't be fudgy.
-
Stir in the chocolate chips, then scrape the batter into the prepared pan. Bake for 30-32 minutes, until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean or with a couple crumbs attached.
-
Sprinkle coarse sea salt over the top, and serve brownies warm, preferably with a generous dollop of vanilla ice cream.
*the espresso powder will not make the brownies taste like coffee - it enhances the chocolate flavor. You can buy it at most grocery stores in the baking aisle, or on Amazon.
Brownies will keep, well-wrapped at room temperature (I pack them tightly in a tupperware), for up to 5 days.
Recipe adapted from my Midnight Brownies and Sally's Baking Addiction.
Like this recipe? Please rate it and leave a comment, and sign up for my email list to receive my recipes straight to your inbox every time I post!
I just found your blog and I am already excited to make these and so many other recipes! I was wondering if replacing white sugar with coconut sugar in this recipe and all you others would make a difference in the result?
Wow. This is the absolute perfect brownie. I’m SO excited (as are my coworkers..) and my taste buds are overjoyed. Before I began baking from scratch, my favorite was the Ghirardelli dark chocolate brownie mix; this is like that, and then even better. The flavor is so rich (I used trader joes bittersweet choco chunks both times i’ve made these; also did use espresso powder) and fudgy, 10x better still warm, and the sea salt flakes on top take it to another level. I love to bake, and brownies have always been one of my favorites. After so many recipes, this is it: the perfect brownie. Everyone, make these. Thank you!!!
Omg Katie this is one of my favorite comments EVER. Thank you so much for the detailed review – I am so glad you (and your lucky coworkers) loved this recipe!!
Hii i’m from the Netherlands and i would love to try this recipe, cause i LOVE browniess! Butt i don’t have a squared pan. I do have round springform pans of 8.66inch 22cm, 9.45inch 24cm and 10.24inch 26cm. Can you please tell wich one i can use for the brownies and how long it needs to bake??
Hi Ikram – I would try the 9.45 inch springform and bake for the same amount of time. Test and see if a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean. If not, bake for 3-5 more minutes and try again. Good luck!
I stumbled upon this recipe while looking at fall recipes and then asked my husband his preference between fudgy Brownies and pumpkin bundt cake. He picked these and I was glad he did 🙂 I’ve also been on the search for a fudgy brownie from scratch and I’ve tried MANY recipes but they’ve always been cakey brownies no matter what so when I saw this recipe sprang from your own search and frustration that were like mine I knew I had to try. I followed the recipe to the letter, I took them out of the oven when the bottom bit of the toothpick had a little thick battery-ness on it, and I let it cool. My husband had his while I was running errands, and he’s usually fairly opposed to desserts that are too rich or too dark chocolatey… and he LOVES these. How can I tell? He had two servings within a few hours despite the calories and he’s never had two brownies in one day from any other recipe. In fact usually I’ll make a batch and he might have two out of the whole batch if I’m lucky. So these are a huge score in our house, I’ll be coming back to this recipe again and again, thank you!!!
Oh my gosh Julie, you have seriously made my month…maybe even my year! THANK YOU for such a wonderful, thoughtful comment. This is exactly why I create recipes – to solve a problem I had that others must be having too. I’m so glad your husband enjoyed these brownies and I hope you always love making them as much as you did the first time! Thanks again.
Can’t wait to make this! Just to verify, 1/4 cup dark chocolate and half cup semi-sweet chocolate chips? Also, is it better to bake with a glass pan or non-stick pan?
Yes – you can just use chocolate chips in place of the dark chocolate as well if that’s all you have. I would bake with a metal pan, as glass heats differently!
I just made these and they are the BOMB! I’ve tried several brownie recipes, but this one really takes the cake! They are chocolatey and have the texture of a boxed brownie, but taste so much better. You won’t be disappointed!
Thank you SO much, Bren! I’m so glad you loved them! They’re seriously my favorite.
OMG These look SO GREAT! I’m going to make these for my husband today 🙂 BTW where did you get that cooling rack? I love it and can’t find anything like it! <3
I hope you liked them!! I got the cooling rack from Williams Sonoma – here’s the link!